Get updates from HorizonMass

OPINION: IN SUPPORT OF THE ENDOWMENT TAX ACT

"MIT Dome night1 Edit" by Fcb981, this edited version by Thermos. CC-BY-SA 3.0 Unported.
"MIT Dome night1 Edit" by Fcb981, this edited version by Thermos. CC-BY-SA 3.0 Unported.

Billions of “nonprofit” colleges’ wealth comes from speculation on Wall Street. Why not tax them for it?


A current bill making the rounds in Massachusetts’ State House, called the Endowment Tax Act (H.2824/ S.1834), is proposing to tax all Massachusetts universities with endowments of more than $1 billion. Unsurprisingly, the richest colleges of Massachusetts, the proposed tax targets, are not so happy about it.

The bill would require all revenue to go towards massively boosting funding to public higher education. If passed, the 2.5 percent tax it would levy would generate at least $2 billion per year as of 2023 according to its House sponsor, Natalie Higgins (D-Leominster).

In addition to concerns about the financial woes it would create for these universities, which I will debunk in the second part of this op-ed, critics have questioned what right the Commonwealth has to tax these private, non-profit institutions at all. “There is no reason to single out particular institutions based on their endowment,” said MIT Economics Chair Jonathan H. Gruber according to the Harvard Crimson

So what right does Beacon Hill have to take money from Harvard University and other private universities in the first place? Especially if these universities have earned that money themselves? 

For one thing, despite purporting to provide a public good, these institutions have refused to enroll more students, all the while the wealth of their endowments has grown exponentially in recent decades. 

But the real catch is that Harvard and company didn’t exactly earn their present fortunes by themselves. No, I’m not talking about donations from billionaire alumni where they endow a new library to get their son admitted. I’m talking about these universities’ ever-growing reliance on the stock market in the form of hedge funds and private equity to balloon their wealth beyond proportion. If you ever hear someone say, “Harvard is just a $51 billion hedge fund with a university attached,” this is why.

Just in 2016, as Astra Taylor of the Nation reported, “experts I consulted estimate that over $100 billion of educational endowment money nationwide is invested in hedge funds, costing them approximately $2.5 billion in fees in 2015 alone.” 

Given the growing push to tax Wall Street more for their often exploitative speculation, shouldn’t we do the same for universities that call themselves non-profits yet have spent the last few decades making billions in profits from speculation on Wall Street? 

It wasn’t always this way: as UC Merced economist and “Bankers in the Ivory Tower” author Charlie Eaton notes, the obscene wealth of these colleges only began in the 1970s. At the time, the growing power of the finance industry led universities to increasingly bring in hedge fund managers to invest their funds intended for education into the stock market. “[F]inanciers helped Princeton increase its endowment by 847 percent from $2 billion in 1973 to $22 billion in 2016,” Eaton said

At this point, it is a matter of saving these institutions from their addiction to money and power above all else. According to Taylor of the Nation, in 2011 over half of all college endowments “allowed board members to do business with the university”. This has made them more beholden to the interests of the hedge funds whose employees increasingly dominate their boards, as this scandal at Dartmouth laid bare.

In turn, this calls into question how beneficial these institutions are for students as opposed to the private equity barons running them. As Julien Berman of the Harvard Crimson wrote, “In 2014, five rich institutions including Harvard paid more to private equity fund managers than they dished out in aid to their entire student bodies.” Meanwhile, another study Berman noted found that endowment increases have no effect on tuition. In other words, Harvard getting more money is not making it any more affordable. 

So if these universities continue to not only acquire unparalleled sums of wealth through shady Wall Street speculation but also refuse to adequately use it for their students, why not tax them and give the proceeds to public universities who will put it to better use? That is what the Endowment Tax sets out to do.

Of course, the Endowment Tax is by no means a silver bullet to the wide range of other challenges Massachusetts’ state schools face today. These range from the exploitation of workers, to rising debts, to reduced funding for cherished humanities and arts programs. 

And nor should this bill be the only solution: these private universities do rely very heavily on their endowments, and excessive taxation would indeed hinder the groundbreaking research and nourishing of promising young minds these schools are famous for. (It just so happens that the amount this bill taxes would not be excessive enough to financially ruin these colleges.)

Nonetheless, achieving anything as monumental as tuition-free college through the Endowment Tax would give us the momentum to face these problems head on. Because passing this bill is not just about more funding, it is about sending a message: that the ultimate service of any university must be to the people. And if they fail in that mission, it is the people’s job to make them do better. 


Liam Rue is a UMass Amherst rising senior studying political science and Spanish. He is also a volunteer communications worker for the Public Higher Education Network of Massachusetts (PHENOM), a Massachusetts nonprofit advocating for the Endowment Tax Act and other legislation aimed at improving the affordability and quality of Massachusetts public higher education.

Thanks for reading and please consider this ...

We see the importance of a strong media and the pitfalls of a lack thereof. If you appreciate articles like this and would like to see more please donate to help keep important news like this available for all to see.

Boston Institute for Nonprofit Journalism not only produces news but works with emerging journalists to help them shape their work and provide vital information to the public.

Started in 2015 BINJ has had dozens of hard hitting news articles that has impacted corporations and government behavior as well as shed light on what's happening where no one else is looking

BINJ operates on an undersized budget hitting far above it's weight class and is one of the leaders in local news and provides leadership in the local news ecosystem.

With your help BINJ can grow beyond it's small staff and strong cohort of freelancers to continue to provide more quality journalism for years to come.
Support Local

Or you can send us a check at the following address:

Boston Institute for Nonprofit Journalism

519 Somerville Ave #206

Somerville, MA 02143

Want to make a stock or in-kind donation to BINJ? Drop us an email at info@binjonline.org and we can make that happen!

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Tags:

Related posts:

Receive the latest news

Subscribe To The HorizonMass Newsletter